As a 30 year old 5'-10" male I have recently fallen back in love with the BMX bike. 
I first dabbled with the bike because of the simplicity - single speed, coaster brake.
Now it is the perfect balance for an in town commuter option.
I forgot to mention that the bike I have came with a "layback" seat post which allows my knees extra handlebar clearance.
 
I suggest the following:
1)  Provide education on the different types of frames available and the advantages of each.
2)  Ultimately it should be the decision of the volunteer based on your availability of stock.
3)  Do not squash their interest now, let them have the BMX
4)  Because they may then come back later for a commuter bike or service
 
 
Austin


 
On 2/18/08, Rich Points <rich@richpoints.com> wrote:
Collectives,
We work with the Boulder County Jail's work release program where inmates begin the program at our shop and Earn-A-Bike.  This past weekend we did a bunch of work in our storage where we keep kids bikes.  Three of the work release guys, in their late twenties and early thirties, found BMX bikes they wanted to keep as their Earn-A-Bike.  Our response was to discourage this as we generally try to set people up with commuter style bikes.  I especially tried to discourage the six foot two guy from choosing a BMX.

We're aware that some people are more than happy to commute by BMX but believe that won't work for most people.  So the question is should we allow the work release guys to choose any bike they want regardless of the practicality?  Are we being elitist bike snobs to make this decision for them?  Should we just be happy we got them back on a bike?

Feedback is appreciated.
-- 
Rich Points
Community Cycles Director
http://CommunityCycles.org
Rich@CommunityCycles.org
720-565-6019

_______________________________________________
Thethinktank mailing list
Thethinktank@bikecollectives.org
http://lists.bikecollectives.org/listinfo.cgi/thethinktank-bikecollectives.org




--
Austin Amos
General Manager
www.conveyweigh.com
Office:  304-201-2354
Mobile:  304-545-6505
Fax:  304-755-3883