We have been having this problem too. What has seemed to work better is having a designated volunteer night with a bunch of task set aside for them. There is always so much to do around the shop that we can’t get done on a regular basis- simple as sweeping the shop and courtyard, cleaning and restocking the back room, restocking and documenting new tubes/what we need more of. These are great for the people who don’t know much about bikes but want to help.