Pals! Thanks so much for your tool board photos and reflections. I have an update from us below, and then links to a photo gallery of everyone's submissions from the Think Tank and Facebook.
Update: we dramatically reduced the number of tools on our main tool boards to just the essentials, and collected the more bikey tools to a single mechanics board and a tool chest. Below is a photo of our new tool board layout https://flic.kr/p/24h3RmG. Charlie's Freewheels in Toronto was our closest model for inspiration: thank you Charlie's!
The new layout has been HUGELY helpful for participants and volunteers.
- People are less intimidated by the boards! The whole situation is more
approachable.
- Things get put back more often and with less hassle.
- Fewer broken and missing tools.
- Better interface for volunteers to help out before participants try a
repair that requires expertise or finesse.
- Easier to expand operations -- we can see adding a second set of tools
to each board on the same pegs as the current ones, with minimal costs and no added confusion.
Also! Taking one cue from the shipping container bike repair station in Winnipeg and another from the short tool boards in Salt Lake City, we also *rearranged the layout of our shop, and it kicks ass.*
- We used to have a shop floor with tool board and benches on the
perimeter and work space in the center. Chaos!
- NOW, we have the benches and tools in the center, and stands on the
perimeter. SO SMOOTH! It's way, way easier and nicer to work.
- We also shortened the heights of the work benches so there's one tall,
one medium, one small.
- AND, because we shortened the heights of the tool boards, you can see
right over them -- so the space feels unified and coherent, not like a bunch of random siloed activities.
Lessons we learned:
- Fewer tools on each board is better for everyone. Couple this with a
master mechanics' board for success.
- Pegboard is the WORST. Plywood and nails 4EVA.
- Yes, mark the boards with tool names and sizes, BUT ALSO: *mark the
tools.* Use an enamel paint marker and clear-coat it with nail polish. This way, new folks can learn the sizes of wrenches and the names of things when they're in hand, and can also easily put them back on the boards.
- In a space like ours, centrally located tools and work benches are
better than peripheral ones, because they improve the flow of people through the space.
Future considerations:
- We're going to add offset brake wrenches to the boards, because they
are so everyday-useful.
- We should have tried doing the outlines with chalk markers, not enamel
markers, so that they're easy to erase and re-do.
- Our work benches are too bulky and big, especially since people do
most of their work in the stand. Less work bench would be fine. By and large, people use them as tables, not work benches. What we really need are just places for folks to put the things they're working with.
- I'd personally like to see the benches get decorated and personalized
by volunteers, but that's a while away for us.
Photo gallery
- Here's everyone's tool boards https://flic.kr/s/aHskuVEvhv! I put
them into a Flickr album. Each filename shows the co-op it came from.
xoxoxo
Josh
Josh Bisker 914-500-9890 New York Mechanical Gardens Bike Co-op http://bikecoop.nyc/ 596 Acres http://596acres.org/ Bindlestiff Family Cirkus http://bindlestiff.org/
